2025
| White Oak Church of the Brethren Red (Manheim CSL)
2024
| Spring Grove (Cumberland League)
2023
| Erb's Mennonite (Manheim CSL)
2022
| Hammer Creek Mennonite (Ephrata CSL)
2021
| Hammer Creek Mennonite (Ephrata CSL)
2020
| No tourney, cancelled due to COVID-19
2019
| Faith Journey (Ephrata CSL)
2018
| Hammer Creek Mennonite (Ephrata CSL)
2017
| Ephrata Church of the Brethren (Ephrata CSL)
2016
| Manheim Mennonite (Manheim CSL)
2015
| Ephrata Church of the Brethren (Ephrata CSL)
2014
| Ephrata Nazarene (Ephrata CSL)
2013
| Ephrata Nazarene (Ephrata CSL)
2012
| Ephrata Nazarene (Ephrata CSL)
2011
| Mountville Mennonite (DACSL)
2010
| Ephrata Bible Fellowship (Ephrata CSL)
2009
| Mummert's/Pleasant Hill COB (Hanover League)
2008
| St. Paul's UCC (Manheim CSL)
2007
| Chiques Church of the Brethren
2006
| Hershey Free Church - Navy (DACSL)
2005
| Mountville Mennonite (DACSL)
2004
| Mountville Mennonite (DACSL)
2003
| Mountville Mennonite (DACSL)
2002
| Harmony Grove
2001
| Aldersgate (York)
2000
| Bosslers Mennonite
1999
| Mt. Calvary
1998
| Mt. Calvary
1997
| (unknown)
1996
| (unknown)
1995
| Hershey Free Church
1994
| Elizabethtown Church of the Brethren
1993
| Chiques Church of the Brethren
1992
| Chiques Church of the Brethren
1991
| Elizabethtown Church of the Brethren
1990
| Shenk's Community
1989
| Shenk's Community
1988
| Mt. Calvary